EOF 1.8RC12 - Now with Rocksmith 2014 support
This topic is 2 years and 4 months old. Instead of replying, please begin a new topic, or search for another related topic that may be more suitable.
aka drumbilical
- italianstal1ion
- Member
- Posts: 1342
- Joined: July 28th, 2007
- Location: Behind a drum set
- Reputation: 57
- Contact:
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
Yeah it's not too bad, just tedious for converting the old charts
OK so I pinpointed the past problem I had months ago. Here's a picture:
Feedback Input
Erase overlapped notes on
(anything else you need to know?)
Picture 1: This is where I intend to paste my notes onto.
Pic 2: This is the selection which I will paste upon the area in Picture 1.
Pic 3: This is what happens when I paste my selection.
The problem, it seems, is that when notes are copied, they are carried in terms of BPM, not what beatline they are on. So even though the measure amount is exactly the same, the notes are pasted as if they are a bit faster (151 BPM onto a 147 BPM measure). What would be ideal is if notes retain their measurement attributes and not their BPM attributes. I just noticed that this only happens in Feedback input mode - the paste function in Piano Roll is exactly what I'd like to have.
OK so I pinpointed the past problem I had months ago. Here's a picture:
Feedback Input
Erase overlapped notes on
(anything else you need to know?)
Picture 1: This is where I intend to paste my notes onto.
Pic 2: This is the selection which I will paste upon the area in Picture 1.
Pic 3: This is what happens when I paste my selection.
The problem, it seems, is that when notes are copied, they are carried in terms of BPM, not what beatline they are on. So even though the measure amount is exactly the same, the notes are pasted as if they are a bit faster (151 BPM onto a 147 BPM measure). What would be ideal is if notes retain their measurement attributes and not their BPM attributes. I just noticed that this only happens in Feedback input mode - the paste function in Piano Roll is exactly what I'd like to have.
Index of all Drum Topics on the Forum in one convenient place
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Jpop fanatic
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5671
- Joined: April 20th, 2008
- Location: Megumi Island
- Reputation: 111
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
italianstal1ion wrote:Yeah it's not too bad, just tedious for converting the old charts
What did you have in mind? Duplicate an entire track to another track, or just duplicate a track difficulty to another?
Picture 1: This is where I intend to paste my notes onto.
Pic 2: This is the selection which I will paste upon the area in Picture 1.
Pic 3: This is what happens when I paste my selection.
The problem, it seems, is that when notes are copied, they are carried in terms of BPM, not what beatline they are on. So even though the measure amount is exactly the same, the notes are pasted as if they are a bit faster (151 BPM onto a 147 BPM measure). What would be ideal is if notes retain their measurement attributes and not their BPM attributes. I just noticed that this only happens in Feedback input mode - the paste function in Piano Roll is exactly what I'd like to have.
I'd probably need a sample project file so I can try to reproduce this. The clipboard stores details for each note including which beat they are in and how far into that beat (percentage) they are.
aka drumbilical
- italianstal1ion
- Member
- Posts: 1342
- Joined: July 28th, 2007
- Location: Behind a drum set
- Reputation: 57
- Contact:
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
raynebc wrote:What did you have in mind? Duplicate an entire track to another track, or just duplicate a track difficulty to another?
I was thinking just to copy the DRUMS track to PS_DRUMS. You don't have to add that though. If you did, it would probably be better not as a menu item. Here's how I'm thinking it could work: If there are notes in the DRUMS track, and you change to the PS_DRUMS track (which EOF recognizes has no notes), then EOF will ask you if you'd like to paste the current DRUMS track into the PS_DRUMS track. EOF would only ask if the PS_DRUMS track had no notes. I mean, this saves like, maybe 2 keystrokes? It's not too important
raynebc wrote:I'd probably need a sample project file so I can try to reproduce this. The clipboard stores details for each note including which beat they are in and how far into that beat (percentage) they are.
Sure, here's a project I made: http://www.mediafire.com/?x35hl1hi8nls8cx
And here is what it looks like:
1: What I am copying
2: What gets copied when I have Feedback controls on
3: What gets copied when I have Piano Roll on (and what I want to happen when I have Feedback on)
Index of all Drum Topics on the Forum in one convenient place
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Jpop fanatic
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5671
- Joined: April 20th, 2008
- Location: Megumi Island
- Reputation: 111
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
italianstal1ion wrote:I was thinking just to copy the DRUMS track to PS_DRUMS. You don't have to add that though. If you did, it would probably be better not as a menu item. Here's how I'm thinking it could work: If there are notes in the DRUMS track, and you change to the PS_DRUMS track (which EOF recognizes has no notes), then EOF will ask you if you'd like to paste the current DRUMS track into the PS_DRUMS track. EOF would only ask if the PS_DRUMS track had no notes. I mean, this saves like, maybe 2 keystrokes? It's not too important
I can make it automatically prompt, but if I added this I might as well make it a menu item as well. Some people may want an easy way to clone a track. Should EOF limit the number of times this prompt is given (ie. only once until the project is re-opened), or should it always ask as long as the PS drum track is empty and the normal drum track isn't?
1: What I am copying
2: What gets copied when I have Feedback controls on
3: What gets copied when I have Piano Roll on (and what I want to happen when I have Feedback on)
Now that I look at this again and you mention that it only happens with Feedback input method, I'm pretty sure it's because in Feedback input method, the keyboard commands for "old paste" (notes don't paste with grid snap information) and "new paste" are swapped. This swap was requested a while back (I couldn't immediately track down who originally requested this change) and implemented in 1.8b39. If you retry the paste with CTRL+P (normally the "old paste" command), I think you'll get the paste you were looking for.
aka drumbilical
- italianstal1ion
- Member
- Posts: 1342
- Joined: July 28th, 2007
- Location: Behind a drum set
- Reputation: 57
- Contact:
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
I requested that feature. The reason I requested that the pastes be changed for Feedback is because I wanted the ability to paste from anywhere in the chart, not for the paste to automatically align with the 1/4th beat. Old paste snaps to a beatline and new paste keeps the notes' BPM information. I made a video with Feedback to demonstrate what I mean: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWu-5JWRAIk
I'm thinking as long as the PS_DRUM track is empty and the DRUMS track isn't. I can't imagine this being annoying to anyone.
I'm thinking as long as the PS_DRUM track is empty and the DRUMS track isn't. I can't imagine this being annoying to anyone.
Index of all Drum Topics on the Forum in one convenient place
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Jpop fanatic
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5671
- Joined: April 20th, 2008
- Location: Megumi Island
- Reputation: 111
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
I think I get what you're asking: You want a paste that is a combination of "old" and "new" paste? The paste would begin at the seek position, and each note pastes the relative amount of grid snaps ahead instead of at the original notes' locations within the beat, ie: in your example, if I copy two notes that are on beat lines, seek 1/16 into a different beat and use the newer paste, the two notes are each pasted 1/16 into the current and next beat?
aka drumbilical
- italianstal1ion
- Member
- Posts: 1342
- Joined: July 28th, 2007
- Location: Behind a drum set
- Reputation: 57
- Contact:
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
raynebc wrote:I think I get what you're asking: You want a paste that is a combination of "old" and "new" paste? The paste would begin at the seek position, and each note pastes the relative amount of grid snaps ahead instead of at the original notes' locations within the beat, ie: in your example, if I copy two notes that are on beat lines, seek 1/16 into a different beat and use the newer paste, the two notes are each pasted 1/16 into the current and next beat?
Yes, that sounds right.
Index of all Drum Topics on the Forum in one convenient place
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
Drum Project 7 Released!
Drum Project 8 Released!
Drum project 9 Released!!
My personal topic.
Can't get enough?
No need to fit in!
- Oddbrother
- Member
- Posts: 96
- Joined: August 12th, 2006
- Reputation: 0
- Contact:
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
I wonder what we're going to call it...
Hybrid paste? Precise paste?
Hybrid paste? Precise paste?
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
raynebc, can you add to EOF a new feature, Flip notes horizontally and vertically, it useful when compress tab in midi-editor(could be wrong tone orientation, you know what i mean) and then import its in EOF (GH-like notes)
Jpop fanatic
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5671
- Joined: April 20th, 2008
- Location: Megumi Island
- Reputation: 111
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
I don't understand what you're asking for. Could you mock up a picture describing it?
Jpop fanatic
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5671
- Joined: April 20th, 2008
- Location: Megumi Island
- Reputation: 111
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
So this would be a function to reflect selected notes horizontally, vertically or both?
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
yeah, like at fl studio alt+Y
so you accept this feature suggestion? :D
so you accept this feature suggestion? :D
Re: EOF 1.8RC5 - Now with Rocksmith export
Hey all! It's been quite a while since I dipped my toes into FoF(iX), and I was never terribly active, but I was quite pleased to see that not only is it still a very active community, EOF is not only maintained but actively being developed! Woohoo!
With that discovery, I pulled some old code off an old hard drive, dusted it off, rebased it to the latest revision and cleaned it up, and...it works! I just filed an issue over at the Google Code repo with patches and details, but basically, it adds the ability to display a spectrogram underneath your notes, just like the waveform option. Spectrograms are a nifty graphical representation of sound that I find useful in lining up tracks. Here's a screenshot of it in action:
More pictures and description over at my imgur album.
With that discovery, I pulled some old code off an old hard drive, dusted it off, rebased it to the latest revision and cleaned it up, and...it works! I just filed an issue over at the Google Code repo with patches and details, but basically, it adds the ability to display a spectrogram underneath your notes, just like the waveform option. Spectrograms are a nifty graphical representation of sound that I find useful in lining up tracks. Here's a screenshot of it in action:
More pictures and description over at my imgur album.
Return to “Tutorials and Tools”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 22 guests